By the brig Porter, which arrived from New Zealand yesterday, accounts have been received of the total wreck of the colonial trading brig Sophia Pate, Captain Harrison, and the melancholy loss of 21 passengers, who were on board that vessel bound to Kiapara (Kaipara), New Zealand.
This vessel left Sydney on the 4th July last, with a cargo of sundries, and 44 passengers, for Auckland, where she safely arrived. On the 12th of August she again sailed from Auckland for Kororareka, and Kiapara, with the following passengers:-
Cabin,Mrs. and Master Harrison, (the Captain's wife and child) and Mr McKie, Steerage Mr and Mrs. Slater
(mispelled name should have been 'Salter') and 10 children, Mr Wilkinson and 4 children, Mr and Mrs Stewart and 2 children, Messrs Stannard and Stephen Ellis; after a boisterous passage of eight days, she arrived at Kororareka, where the Captain touched to procure a person to pilot the vessel in the Kaipara, there being none on board who had any previous knowledge of the entrance to that port.
The captain being unable to procure any person who would undertake to bring the vessel round to Kiapara, offered to remit part of the passage money to the passengers, if they would leave and go overland to Kiapara, a distance of 20 miles. This proposal being refused, the Captain set sail, after three day's detention, having however taken on board three additional seaman and Mr Hughs. Mr Stewart, and Mr. Stannard; two of the passengers left the ship and travelled overland to Kiapara to endeavour to procure a pilot there, before the brig arrived, and Mr. McKie , another of the passengers left the ship and returned to Sydney on the Jane.
After a run of two days, she arrived off Kaipara, where she lay-to for 24 hours, till the wind had a little appeased. In running into the bay every caution was taken - a seaman was stationed in the fore-topmast to look out for breakers, and another in the main chains for sounding, but of no avail. She struck at 4 p.m. upon one of the sand banks on the south side of the bay. They remained in this state till 10 o'clock, when she separated.
During this time, the most of the passengers were washed overboard, even the captain's son, who has been saved, went twice over with the roll of the sea. The following parties were saved by betaking themselves to the jolly boat: - Captain Harrison, Edward Tavener (First Mate), N. Harrison (second mate), six seamen, two children, and Mr. John Wilkinson, passenger.
The bodies of Mrs Salter, and two of her children Sarah and Martha, Mrs Stewart and her son Alfred, were washed ashore and interred by the seamen who remained for three days at the scene of devastation.
The Sophia Pate was the property of Messrs Harper, Blundell, & Co., who have suffered considerably by the loss of this ship, as she was only insured for the sum of L2500.
Subscriptions were being got up at Auckland for the benefit of the unfortunate survivors.
From the
Freeman's Journal & Daily Commercial Advertiser (Dublin, Ireland) Thursday January 20th 1842 -
provided by LisaMOST CALAMITOUS EVENT - MELANCHOLY LOSS OF LIFE
We regret much to have to record an occurrence which, as bringing deep affliction to several respectable families in this city, could scarcely be exceeded.
In the month of November 1840, three or four families of this city, remarkable for their industry and prosperity in their respective lines of business, including Mr James Salter, his wife and ten children, a respectable jeweller, residing for many years in the Grand Parade, - Mr. John Wilkinson, wife and four children, boot and shoe maker, of Daunt's Square - Mr Stannard of Hammonds Marsh, we believe a cabinetmaker - broke up their respective establishments, and sailed in the ship Neptune for Sydney, their place of destination being New Zealand.
Mr Salter had made an extensive purchase of property in New Zealand, through the agency of a friend who had been there and reported most favourably of the country, and took out a considerable quantity of plate and other property.
The Neptune arrived at Sydney in good order, and the emigrants landed, and sojourned there some three or four months. Mr Salter made provision there for one of his sons.
Matters being in readiness, and all arrangements perfected the families of Messrs Salter, Wilkinson, and Stannard proceeded in the month of August last, in the clipper Sophia Pate from Sydney, and arrived after a run of about three weeks in the Bay of Islands. Here having stopped a short time, Mr Stannard proposed to walk across the country, about fifteen miles distant, to the spot towards which they had looked for months in that spirit of anxiety and solicitude natural under the circumstances.
The proposition to walk overland was not agreed to by Mr Salter or Mr Wilkinson, upon the ground that it may not be prudent in them to leave their trunks and boxes to the care of others, and Mr Stannard accompanied by one of Mr Wilkinson's sons, set off, leaving the remainder to proceed coastways.
Upon arriving at the destined spot he was astonished that no tidings of the vessel had been received, and he immediately proceeded to the residence of the chief, of whom the property had been purchased for Mr Salter, and whose welcome was most gracious. Accompanied by a Methodist Missionary, in connexion with the London Institution, and a number of followers, the chief proceed to the harbour as being likely selected as a landing place for the clipper, when they were met by the master and crew, wearing Mr Salter's clothes.
Explanation quickly followed. The master reported that when close to shore the vessel struck, and had gone to pieces, and that all on board, except himself, the hands and a child of Mr. Wilkinson had perished.
The chief, and extremely intelligent man, instantly suspected that all was not right; his suspicions extended to his followers, and it was only by the greatest exertions of the missionary that the natives were prevented from tearing the crew limb from limb.
A portion of poor Mr. Slater's property, in plate, was found on the captain; and he and his crew being first stripped of the clothes on them, were conveyed to Auckland, a principal town in New Zealand, to await their trials.
Young Mr. Wilkinson is stated to have represented that when the ship struck Mr Salter entreated the captain to lower the long boat, and he did lower her, but it was to send her adrift; upon which he was asked to let down the jolly boat.
He refused at first; but upon letting her down he and the crew lowered themselves into her, providently pushing young Wilkinson, in the confusion before them. He got to the bottom of the boat, and thus escaped, the last scene he witnessed on board was Mr. Salter and family at prayer in the cabin, which at this time was filling fast with water.
These are some of the particulars of this severe calamity, derived from a source on which we implicitly rely - Southern Reporter
After the wreck
Reports concerning Captain George Harrison
October 1841From the Sydney Gazette & New South Wales Advertiser
23rd October 1841 Pg 3
Captain Harrison of the Sophia Pate
We have been authorised by J.A. Murray Esq, passenger on the Julia, from New Zealand to give an unqualified contradiction in the yesterday's Herald, to the purport that Captain Harrison had been detained in Auckland on a charge of murder, from he, and the men under his command had acted in the most brutal and inhuman manner, by preventing some of the passengers saving themselves, when the Sophia Pate was lost - so far from this being the case, or chopping off the hands of those, who it is said attempted to escape, by grasping at the boat, he used every effort that was possible to save their lives.
Captain H., instead of being guilty of the conduct ascribed to him, had it not in his power to save his own wife, who was drowned. Captain Fox denies giving any information that could lead the Herald thus to libel the character of Captain Harrison.
May 1842
From the Sydney Gazette & New South Wales Advertiser 17th May 1842
The Sophia Pate
Having at the time this vessel was wrecked, mentioned several rumours prejudicial to Captain Harrison's conduct, we think it our duty to make the following extract from a late number of the Auckland Standard, by which it will be seen that his conduct was blameless -
Captain Harrison and the crew of the Sophia Pate -
Everyone remembers the disastrous wreck of this vessel, about six months ago, in the harbour of Kiapara. The loss of life caused a very strong sensation; and it appearing on an investigation, that the poor cast aways nearly naked and destitute, had picked up a few things, of no great value, which belonged to passenger, the captain and the crew were committed for trial at the Supreme Court.
These people, seven in all, were detained for nearly six months before the sittings came on. The Attorney General (who was not in the colony at the time of their committal), refused to find a bill, so they were not called upon to appear. Amongst the sufferers, it may be remembered, was the captain's young and beloved wife; but his son twelve months old, was preserved by miracle, the men resolved to save 'little Bobby', as they used to term him, when the nurse and him were on deck.
We can assure the numerous friends of Captain Harrison, both at home and in the colonies, that he will leave this, the scene of his disasters and troubles, without a stain upon his character, or any cause for reflection upon his professional skill.
.......more of this post will be coming very shortly
Further research notes:An interesting post about James Salter Snr regarding Silversmith Hallmarks on
Silver Collector.comAlso on James Salter Snr again
Silversmiths & Allied Trades Cork - 1824 (link provided by
Lisa)
From the Auckland Chronicle April 18 1844 (?)
Ships to Australia Website 1844 March-May -
Secondary source I will have to view the Commercial Journal of the time to confirm this article.
THE “SOPHIA PATE”—This wreck has caused more speculation than most of the people of Auckland are aware of. She has been sold to five or six different parties, all of whom tried their best to raise her, but without success; the present owner Mr Morley, is likely to succeed better than any of the others, he has succeeded in cutting the cable, and we understand the vessel has risen by this act four feet. We trust as Mr Morley is a very enterprising man he may be rewarded for his labour, and the poor fellows who toil night and day with him in his undertaking—Auckland Chronicle April 18.Sophia Pate
Passenger List (transciption not primary source) 3rd July 1841 from the Sydney Free Press & Commercial Journal 6th July 1841
Sydney (3 Jul 1841) to Auckland
Under Captain Harrison
Ash Miss
Kitchen Mrs
Kitchen Miss
Stanley Mrs
Mitford Mr
Johnson Mr I.
Johnson Mr W.
Dalsey Mr
Mackie Mr
Cooper Mr
The arrival of the Neptune from Port Phillip Sydney Gazette & New South Wales Advertiser 20th April 1841From Port Phillip, same day, whence she sailed the 14th instant, the ship Neptune. Captain Ferris, with sundries. Passengers, Mr. Harpur, Mr. Wetty, Mr. King Lake, Mr. Smith, Mr.and Mrs. Salter and ten children.Mr. Blake, Mr. Stannard, seven steerage passengers, and forty-three emigrants.
Land Claim Notifications from
The Daily Southern Cross 10th February 1844 in which the names James Salter (Jnr), John Wilkinson and George Stannard are mentioned as being amongst the claimants
A brief background for Rev. George Stannard on
NZETC where reference to the event of the wreck is made
Chapter 12 The Rev. George Stannard : from Maori and Missionary: Early Christian Missions in the South Island of New Zealand. Author T. A. Pybus (1954)
STANNARD - On the 8th instant at Victoria Avenue, Wanganui the Rev. George Stannard aged 86.
Rev. James Buller's Account written in 1878 -
40 Years in New Zealand. Personal Narrative Part 1 Chapter X Sophia Pate
* Because of the length of time between the actual event and the writing of his memoirs this account may not be entirely accurate however most of Rev Buller's account does concur with those of the reports of the time. It should be noted however there is a discrepancy in this account as to which ship the families of Salter,Stannard,Stewart and Wilkinson came on from Sydney. Also Chartered could have meant the families had arrived on the Sophia Pate then chartered her from that point for the voyage to Kaipara I'm speculating on this but perhaps that was what Rev. Buller was referring to?
Perils of the Sea 19th Century from
Te Ara mentions the difficulty concerning the the navigation of the Kaipara Harbour in the 19th Century
......The coastline was poorly charted. For example, when the Sophia Pate tried to enter Kaipara Harbour in 1841, the captain had three charts, each indicating a different channel to follow. He chose one, and the brig became stuck on a sand bank, resulting in the loss of 21 lives.
Also from Te Ara -
Kaipara Harbour Charts with the Sophia Pate mentioned
Australian Ships Passenger lists -
Oz Ships - link provided by Ashley
Mentioned in The Trail of Waitangi Website concerning a
journey from Manukau to Paihia 1842 by Colenso
Mentioned in South Head -
An article on South Head Kaipara by the Helensville Historical Society
Mentioned in a Poem about Harbours on
Smithy on Line Website